The record
The Washington State Health Care Authority (HCA) admitted it underreported the state's CHIP spending to the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for 2020-2025.
Because federal allotments are calculated from reported spending, Washington's CHIP allotment was cut by roughly $250 million per year, to about $133 million per year, starting federal fiscal year 2024.
CMS alerted HCA to the problem in January 2024. State budget writers and the Office of Financial Management were not told until Senate staff surfaced it on October 28, 2026.
The widely repeated $654 million figure is a projection through FY2031 that assumes the reduced allotment stays frozen. The hard, documented component is roughly $100 million.
No fraud or ineligible payments have been alleged by anyone with the record. The money that was spent covered eligible children. The error ran against the state's own interest -- the state shorted itself.
The audit
Citizens are running an unofficial external audit themselves. This is not an internal review -- an agency grading its own homework is how a known problem stays quiet for two years. It is running now, and it runs continuously. How it operates:
- The money is small and accounted for in the open. The costs are public-records fees and this site's domain. If any money is ever collected, it is held with published accounts and spent only on those costs, with every receipt published here. Nobody involved holds Washington state contracts.
- No firm is hired and nobody is licensed. The work is done by citizens, coordinated by Natalie Cole-Clift Spiva acting as proxy. This is unofficial by design -- it claims no authority except the evidence.
- The scope is the public record. Reconcile what the state reported to CMS against what the state actually spent -- both are records the public can get. Add public-records requests for the paper trail of the January 2024 warning: who received it, who read it, who decided the budget writers didn't need to know.
- AI assists with the reading. Sorting records as they come in, extracting the figures from the documents, lining up what was reported against what was spent across five years, and flagging discrepancies. Nothing is published on a flag alone -- every figure goes up with a public copy of the source document it came from, so any reader can re-check it.
- Everything is published on this website -- the findings, the methods, the working papers, and public copies of the source documents themselves -- free for anyone to read, download, and check.
This method is not built for one agency. It works on any part of Washington state government whose numbers are public -- which is most of them. The Health Care Authority's CHIP reporting is case one because the record is admitted and the arithmetic is checkable today. New cases open as the record surfaces, and the method does not change: public money, public records, public copies, published findings.
The record, in one place
This site is a records desk, not just a report. Every document the audit obtains is published here in full, organized by case -- records pulled from the government's own public postings, wherever they were scattered, and records released under Washington's Public Records Act or the federal Freedom of Information Act.
What is posted here is the document itself, not a description of it. Beside each document, the request that produced it and its date are logged, so the trail from asking to receiving is part of the record too. And if a record was withheld or a request denied, that is posted as well, with the reason the agency gave -- a refusal is part of the record, not the end of it.
How it works, exactly
- Money, handled in the open. The costs are small by design -- public-records fees and this site's domain. Any money collected is held with published accounts, spent only on records fees and site costs, and every receipt is published here. One conflict-of-interest rule: nobody involved holds Washington state contracts.
- Publish the method first. Before any numbers go up, this site posts exactly how the work is done -- what is compared, what counts as a discrepancy, how figures get checked -- so the method can be criticized before the results exist.
- Assemble the two sets of numbers (see the sources section below).
- Reconcile. What the state reported is lined up against what the state actually spent, period by period across 2020-2025. Every discrepancy found is classified and quantified.
- Follow the paper trail. Public records requests go in for the January 2024 CMS warning: who received it, who read it, what was decided, and why budget writers were not told. Every request, every response, every delay, and every denial is logged publicly on this site as it happens.
- AI does the reading, the proxy does the assembling, and the public does the verifying. AI tools sort records, extract figures, and flag discrepancies. Nothing is published on a flag alone: every figure is published together with a public copy of the source document it came from, so any reader can re-check it in one click. Nothing is signed, because nothing here is official -- the copies are the credential.
- Publish everything. Findings, methods, working papers, and the underlying documents themselves go on this site, free, the same day they are delivered to the State Auditor, the legislature, and the press.
- Correct in the open. If a figure on this site turns out to be wrong, it is fixed publicly, with the change and the reason recorded in a corrections log on this page. No silent edits.
Where the information comes from
- What the state reported: the financial reports the Health Care Authority files with the federal Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services for the CHIP program. These are federal filings.
- What the state actually spent: Washington's own public fiscal records -- the state accounting data published at fiscal.wa.gov, Office of Financial Management budget documents, and legislative fiscal reports.
- The allotment math: the federal CHIP allotment figures CMS publishes for each state, which are calculated from reported spending.
- The paper trail: records requested under Washington's Public Records Act (RCW 42.56) from the Health Care Authority, the Office of Financial Management, and the Governor's office.
- The figures on this page: drawn from the Health Care Authority's public admissions as reported by Axios Seattle and The Center Square in November 2026, Senate Ways & Means staff estimates, and statements from the Office of Financial Management. Where a number is a projection rather than a documented amount -- the $654 million -- this site says so, and gives the documented component (roughly $100 million) alongside it.
- What cannot be obtained: records the law exempts from disclosure, and anything that was never written down. Every denied request is listed here with the exemption claimed, so the gaps in the record are as public as the record itself.
The honest limits
This is unofficial. Its findings carry no legal authority and compel nothing; they persuade only as far as the evidence carries them. It has no subpoena power and cannot compel anyone to sit for an interview. It uses only records the public can obtain -- if a record is not public, it is not used, and the gap is listed here, so the holes in the record are as public as the record itself. This site can only post what is already public or what an agency releases; it cannot compel production -- which is exactly why the records requests are filed, and why every answer, delay, and denial is logged here.
The costs are small by design: public-records fees and a few dollars a year for this site's domain, and every receipt is published here.
Findings
Case 1: Health Care Authority -- CHIP reporting. Case 1 is open. The record is being assembled and checked; findings will be published here as they are verified, each with its public source copies.
Future cases will be listed here as they open. Any Washington state agency is in scope.
Documents held -- Case 1
- MACPAC Exhibit 34 -- Federal CHIP Allotments, four editions (covering FYs 2020-2022, 2021-2023, 2022-2024, and 2023-2025; PDF, plus a spreadsheet of the latest edition): Washington's federal CHIP allotment by year, as published across four vintages.
- MACPAC Exhibit 33 -- CHIP Spending by State, FFY2020, 2022, 2023, and 2024 (PDF, plus a spreadsheet for FFY2024): what Washington's CHIP spending was reported as, by year.
- MACPAC MACStats Data Book, December 2022 (full book, PDF): the source of the FFY2021 Exhibit 33 figures for Washington.
- HHS TAGGS award records for Washington CHIP, FFY2020-FFY2027 (eight award pages): the federal grant award actions -- dates and exact dollar amounts -- behind each year's allotment.
- TAGGS action extract (working text file): the award dates, types, and amounts pulled from the TAGGS pages into one list.
- CMS-21 Annual CHIP Expenditures Reports, FFY2020-FFY2024 (five archives, workbooks extracted): the federal CHIP FMR Net Expenditures workbooks, with a sheet per state.
- Washington CMS-21 extract (working text file): Washington's three sheets -- Medicaid-expansion CHIP, the federal-share adjustment sheet, and separate CHIP -- pulled out of the workbooks.
- CMS-21 annual reports index page (Medicaid.gov, as retrieved): the federal index of the annual expenditure reports.
- Declaration in U.S. District Court, W.D. Wash., Case 2:25-cv-00127-JCC, Document 14 (PDF, filed January 21, 2025): includes a table of forecasted state fiscal year 2025 HCA physical-health expenditures, with a CHIP (Children) line.
- The Center Square report on the Senate staff email (syndicated copy): the only public window on the October 28, 2026 staff email -- the $654 million figure and its parts, as quoted and paraphrased by the press.
- Post Millennial summary of the reporting: a derivative account of the Axios and Center Square stories, including HCA's stated objections to the staff math.
- OFM news release on the November 2026 revenue forecast: the Governor's budget office's posted forecast release -- held here in part because it does not mention CHIP at all.
These are the audit's working copies. They will be downloadable from this page once the site is live.
Tell us where it breaks
This audit is published as it runs, on purpose: so its flaws can be found in the open, the same standard it asks of the state. If you can see where it breaks -- the law, the money, the records, the method -- say so. And you can point at any agency, any program, any decision: everything in Washington state government is in scope. The proxy reads and answers comments on her public Facebook page, and corrections are posted here, on the record.